Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
.:HOME:. -> LUMSS Forum -> LUMSS Forum -> Is gathering to recite Ya-Sin Bidaah
Post Info TOPIC: Is gathering to recite Ya-Sin Bidaah
Deedat


Status: Offline
Posts: 148
Date:
Is gathering to recite Ya-Sin Bidaah
Permalink  

Asm,


 


To those whom very concern about above matter. The imam of the mosque told me that the gathering and reading Ya-sin recitation is bidaah (as usual). As I'm not the scholar but muslim statistician, without doing any further/other judgements please read these links.


http://qa.sunnipath.com/issue_view.asp?HD=1&ID=831&CATE=3


http://qa.sunnipath.com/issue_view.asp?HD=7&ID=2003&CATE=105


http://qa.sunnipath.com/issue_view.asp?HD=1&ID=832&CATE=3


http://qa.sunnipath.com/issue_view.asp?HD=7&ID=4274&CATE=105


Oh Allah please guided us to the correct path.  Please fullfil our soul with the soul of Quran. Fullfil the atmosphere of our home with Quran (everyday).  Give us strength to follow your trully commandments. Please not include us amongts people who are hating and forgetting the Quran and it ayahs. Ameen.


 


Allah knows the best.


Bakri.


 


ps:Remember those people mentioned above are for who are able to recite and already learn the Quran correctly. But not for those who are still learning... or sangkut-sangkut bila baca or tajwid kelam-kabut in case salah sebut jadi salah makna. BUT..


the latter people can alway "niah" to learn when reciting.............



-- Edited by Deedat at 21:16, 2006-02-24

-- Edited by Deedat at 21:34, 2006-02-24

-- Edited by Deedat at 21:45, 2006-02-24

__________________
Sabar menanti hari .... Tenang menunggu waktu... Khusyuk meniti masa...
Deedat


Status: Offline
Posts: 148
Date:
Yasin for the dead
Permalink  

Additional information to those are concern...


http://qa.sunnipath.com/issue_view.asp?HD=3&ID=4377&CATE=345


 



__________________
Sabar menanti hari .... Tenang menunggu waktu... Khusyuk meniti masa...
aku


Status: Offline
Posts: 101
Date:
RE: Is gathering to recite Ya-Sin Bidaah
Permalink  


Thanks for the info. If anybody else has input from different sources, please share.


Just one thing I'm not clear on when you said......




ps:Remember those people mentioned above are for who are able to recite and already learn the Quran correctly. But not for those who are still learning... or sangkut-sangkut bila baca or tajwid kelam-kabut in case salah sebut jadi salah makna.




Does it mean if my recital is not perfect (ie still learning or sangkut2 bila baca or tajwid kelam-kabut), I'm not allowed to join and recite together with those who are perfect? Or I can join but only allowed to listen?


 



__________________
aku


Status: Offline
Posts: 101
Date:
Permalink  

Fatwa-fatwa dari Jawatankuasa Fatwa Majlis Kebangsaan Bagi Hal Ehwal Agama Islam Malaysia.


Fatwa Yang Telah diWartakan Negeri-Negeri di Malaysia


 



__________________
Deedat


Status: Offline
Posts: 148
Date:
Permalink  

Asm,

Apologize ... Ijan, I have no appropriate answer for that!!. Learning need gurus. I'm still learning the Quran, more I learn more I don't know (especially I almost forgotten the Arabic language which I learn during my secondary school-compulsary subject and got distinction..)!!! I still find that many things and area of Quran lacks of my knowledge (poor me). I learn and learn Quran from many people, and keep searching within my time for new knowledge about Quran. Here I have only one Quran guru left as another gurus that I have learned already got PhD and left last year. Any feeling when reading Quran? Any body bored when reading Quran? Or never bother to learn Quran. Or never read it since came to Lancaster!!! Or never try to correct at least the Fatihah with someone better than us? Sometimes I'm really afraid to read the Quran because what the Quran said I am not fully obeyed....a lot of things.. But please never give up learning it and read it in your capability hope Allah give you His rewards.

SubhanaAllah Quran really the miracle from Allah swt. Our Prophet sometimes likes to listen from Abu Musa (one of the sahabat who are very good in reciting) recited the Quran. Both whom are reading and listening get the benefit from Allah swt InsyaAllah.

Allah knows best.

Bakri

ps:
I'm a talib. (talib mean student) Taliban mean (two students)


-- Edited by Deedat at 16:54, 2006-02-27

__________________
Sabar menanti hari .... Tenang menunggu waktu... Khusyuk meniti masa...
aku


Status: Offline
Posts: 101
Date:
Permalink  

ish...ish...ish.


you gave some very good links regarding reciting al-quran in a group... at the same time you said that it is only "for who are able to recite and already learn the Quran correctly. But not for those who are still learning... or sangkut-sangkut bila baca or tajwid kelam-kabut in case salah sebut jadi salah makna."


the links says it's ok but you put a condition to that.... aku jadik konpius... so, i just want to clarify..... conclusion nye boleh tak kita baca yaasin beramai2 as practiced before?



__________________
Deedat


Status: Offline
Posts: 148
Date:
No Comment
Permalink  

Asm, Ijan.

The argument put on hold, please wait until the religous member appointed asking some ustaz in MSD. Ustaz Rahim is a suitable person to give some answers with the dalil I hope. Did anybody observed when any Sultan die how the Qaris read in group simultinously or in group but Qari by Qari read the Quran? Do they just read the Yasin.

Sorry again Ijan I might made a statement on the save side. BUT I MIGHT BE WRONG. Put in mind that I'm only a muslim statistician.

This is the last post for this issue from me. Thank you for reading and hope some of us are looking for some answers.

-- Edited by Deedat at 22:57, 2006-02-27

__________________
Sabar menanti hari .... Tenang menunggu waktu... Khusyuk meniti masa...
aku


Status: Offline
Posts: 101
Date:
RE: Is gathering to recite Ya-Sin Bidaah
Permalink  

 


Fine. ok.



__________________
aku


Status: Offline
Posts: 101
Date:
Permalink  

Quote from a bloq............. moga bermanfaat.




<start quote>
Here are some links which looks at the concept of innovation and bida’ah from the perspective of some respected Sunni Muslim scholars.


The Concept of Bid’a in the Islamic Shari’a by Shaikh Nuh Ha Mim Keller
Kissing the Thumbs and Wiping One’s Eyes During the Adhan - a partake on an alleged bid’ah practise by Shaikh Faraz Rabbani
Understanding the Four Madhabs by Shaikh Abdul Hakim Murad
Is the Mawlid Bid’aah? - opinions from Sheikh `Atiyyah Saqr and Sheikh Yusuf Al-Qaradawi
<end quote>



__________________
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.
.:HOME:. -> LUMSS Forum -> LUMSS Forum -> Is gathering to recite Ya-Sin Bidaah
Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse 		Powered by ActiveBoard